Business owners often find a competitor recommended by ChatGPT despite having superior reviews or more experience. This is not random. AI assistants favor businesses with clear, consistent information found across trusted sources online.
Reasons for AI Recommendations
The primary reason is inconsistent business details. If a Google profile lists “Smith Plumbing Pty Ltd” while the website says “Smith’s Plumbing” and an old directory has a different phone number, the AI cannot confidently identify the business as a single entity.
Another major factor is a lack of third-party mentions. AI tools rely heavily on industry associations, news articles, and directories. Your own website praising your services is less effective than an editorial feature or a supplier page mentioning you. This is the big one.
Website content also plays a role. Vague descriptions like “professional services across Melbourne” provide little for an AI to reference. A competitor’s specific page titled “Commercial Electrician in Dandenong,” with direct answers about pricing and licensing, is much more useful.
Improving Your AI Visibility
Fixing your online listings is the first step. Choose one official version of your name, address, phone number, and website. Ensure every listing, including Google Business Profile, Bing Places, and Apple Business Connect, matches this information exactly.
Earn genuine mentions from external sources. Respond to journalist inquiries, apply for editorial features, and appear on relevant podcasts. Never purchase links, as this can harm your standing. More on doing it properly: https://www.intriguedigital.com.au/news/how-to-get-backlinks-small-business
Make your website’s content clear and specific. Create a separate page for each service. Name the locations you serve in plain text. Provide short, direct answers to common customer questions about price, timing, and licensing.
Your reviews should be detailed. Twenty five-star reviews saying “Great service” are less helpful than ten reviews explaining a specific job, like “Fixed our hot water system the same day in Geelong.” You can’t script reviews or pay for them, but you can ask customers to mention what you did for them.
Ensure your website can be read by AI crawlers. Some sites block them accidentally through their robots.txt file or use JavaScript that crawlers cannot process. Fix: ask your web developer to check that search and AI crawlers can access your important pages, and that your key content shows up in the page’s HTML.
Keep all information current. Outdated prices, closed locations, or discontinued services reduce trust. Fix: review your service pages, listings, and FAQs at least twice a year.
Listing fixes and site improvements can show up quickly. Third-party mentions build more slowly but have the biggest effect. The takeaway: When AI recommends your competitor, it’s telling you what it can and can’t find about you. Fix your consistency, earn genuine mentions, make your pages specific, and keep them current.
Leave a Reply